Monday, 14 March 2011

Marc Lievremont's madness destroying French rugby

My second favourite rugby team has always been France.
They always seemed so glamorous, so exciting to watch and spectacularly unpredictable.
French teams always seemed to have some sort of edge hidden under a layer of studied nonchalance and incidentally, the best kit in the six nations.
Add in the fact that they actually won matches; it often made them a much more enticing prospect than Scotland.
It is therefore somewhat unfortunate that they now seem to be led by a madman.
Marc Lievremont has never really been convincing as head coach of France.
He did win a grand slam in the 2010 six nations but in three years he has named a staggering 81 different players to play for France.
His previous low as coach was a 59-16 defeat last autumn at home against Australia but the humbling 22-21 defeat against Italy is even more humiliating.
More embarrassing perhaps though, could be Lievremont’s reaction to the, accusing his players of betraying the national jersey.
He said: “they betrayed us, they betrayed me and they have betrayed the French national team shirt.
“In terms of the tactics deployed, it defied belief. I did not recognise anything in their performance that we had worked on.
“Do you really think play told them to play as they did against Italy? I was ashamed. I do not have the impression that we asked them to walk on the moon. I do not ask for complicated things. This match was a hallucination. I do not want to clear myself but they invented things on the pitch,” he said.
In terms of bizarre sporting reactions it is right up there with the last time a French national team went into meltdown – last summer during the Football world cup when the players turned on their coach Raymond Domenech.
The similarities are striking, the combination of poor results and eccentric management are leading the French rugby team into mire.
Lievremont reacted has reacted to the Italy defeat by dropping several experienced players from his squad – Sebastian Chabal, Yannick Jauzion, Clement Poitrenaud, Jerome Thion, Sylvain Marconnet and Aurelian Rougerie have all been released.
Judging by Lievremont’s words many of them are unlikely to return.
“They are lacking in courage,” he said.
“They are good guys but they are cursed with what is clearly cowardice. They are not even capable of recognising their mistakes.”
This seems a bit rich coming from Lievremont who has never acknowledged his part in dragging French rugby into a downward spiral.
His first act as coach was to call up a load of little known and inexperienced players to the French team to make a point to the bigger clubs.
Of these, only Morgan Parra and Francois Trinh-Duc have established themselves as regulars and only Parra looks truly comfortable on the international scene.
His selection against Italy saw him drop the two outstanding forwards in his team Thomas Domingo and Imanol Harinordiquy in favour of veterans Marconnet and Chabal who both looked well off the pace of international rugby, even against Italy.
God help them against the All Blacks of New Zealand at the World Cup.
The French performance was muddled and confused with no discernable shape or game plan.
For Lievremont to absolve himself of all blame is ridiculous and will further drive a wedge between himself and his players.
The swagger and the verve has gone from French rugby.
Lievremont has ripped the magic out of them and it is a great shame.
Perhaps it isn’t the greatest French team ever but they are certainly capable of playing at a far higher standard than this.
Normally firing a coach just before a world cup would look like suicide.
For France at the moment the opposite is true, Lievremont must go.
He was given a chance to redeem himself after the world cup but all he has done is drag his team further into the mire.
On the bright side they still have the best kit.

Monday, 7 March 2011

Quality rugby in the six nations - not really.

Is it just me, or is the standard of rugby in the six nations not that good?
It has been intense certainly, with several absorbing matches the France games against Ireland and England.
However, from a quality point of view there has not been anything that will have New Zealand, Australia or South Africa quaking ahead of the world cup this autumn.
Games have been scrappy for the most part, still devilled by inconsistent refereeing, especially at the scrum.
England look certain to win the championship though a trip to Dublin on the final weekend could derail their hopes of a Grand Slam. Of all the teams they have shown the most attacking intent with Toby Flood the only playmaker in the tournament that looks happy playing on the gain line and indeed breaking it.
Although Chris Ashton has taken the plaudits for his finishing, it has been Flood that has put in for his tries.
Ben Youngs has also been hugely impressive and his attacking threat round the fringes has made the space further out for Flood.
Considering how Scotland have defended round the side of rucks, I would be surprised if we do not see Youngs make a few breaks during the Calcutta Cup match this Sunday.
Their pack have been impressive too despite missing Tom Croft, Courtney Lawes and Lewis Moody.
Tom Wood has taken to international rugby as if he was born to play it and James Haskell is finally delivering on his potential.
However, they still have a few huge flaws, Hape at twelve is certainly huge but he is a deeply flawed player. He offers very little in attack for a start. We keep hearing about his offloading game but there has been little evidence of this. His defence is also poor and he has been caught out of position several times in the tournament. Mike Tindall outside him has been little better with some horrible mistakes that a player with his experience simply shouldn’t be making. He genuinely seems incapable of passing the ball and he offers just as much with the ball in hand as Hape, not a lot. He is at least solid in defence but his lack of pace is there to be exploited.
Until England can find some international standard centres they are going to be limited in what they can achieve. They will be boosted up front by a return for the above mentioned trio, especially Croft who is their one genuinely world class forward. However, I would still expect them to lose against the southern giants more often than they would beat them.
France have been very disappointing.
When you consider the players available to them they should be much more impressive than they are.
They should have lost to Ireland and would have done if it wasn’t for Ireland constantly giving away penalties in dangerous positions. They beat Scotland thanks to some inspired counter attacks, proof that they are still capable of turning on the magic. However, for the most part they have been stodgy with an aging set of forwards who relish the fight up front but aren’t too keen on flowing running rugby. This policy of big is best is prevalent in the backs too with the continuing selection of the aging Yannick Jauzion and Damien Traille, formally brilliant, now past it.
Australia tore them to shreds in the autumn and would do it again now, it’s just none of the other six nations teams are capable of exploiting weaknesses in the way the southern hemisphere giants do.
Ireland have some things to be pleased with. Another aging team , they are starting to show signs of finding the talent to replace the fading stars post world cup. Mike Ross and Cian Healy seem to finally be the answer to the front row problems that have dogged them and a back row of Stephen Ferris, Sean O’Brien and Jamie Heaslip will be the best in the northern hemisphere.
Luke Fitzgerald continues to develop nicely at full back and could well be, long term, the man who fills Brian O’Driscoll’s thirteen jersey.
However, in the short term, they are still reliant on Ronan O’Gara’s boot to win them games and their discipline is suspect. Paul O’Connell is another who is beginning to show his age.
They simply aren’t good enough to compete with the best in the world, a fact that is true of all the six nations teams. England are the best equipped to compete but the only team I would be willing to put money on for the world cup would be New Zealand. If they don’t win it, Australia will.
Meanwhile, let’s sit back and enjoy some clunky but competitive fare from the six nations.